Chicken Tortilla Soup {Instant Pot, Stovetop, Slow Cooker}
Simple, healthy, and delicious, this best ever chicken tortilla soup can be made on the stovetop, in the pressure cooker or with a slow cooker. Awesome!
Chicken Tortilla Soup is both amazing and delicious.
It is one of my favorite soups in all the world. There’s something about piling all those toppings on top of the soup and relishing the 1001 flavors that just gets me.
I’ve been wanting a killer version of chicken tortilla soup for a while, and not only does this fit the bill for tremendous flavor and tastiness, it also gets major bonus points for versatility.
Make it in the Instant Pot, on the stovetop or in the slow cooker.
I know. The options. They are glorious and wonderful.
I’ve included directions for all three cooking methods, and it really is delicious however you choose to make it.
If I had to commit, I’d say my preference is definitely making it in the pressure cooker, because I’m madly in love with my Instant Pot…just like half the world is also after Black Friday and Christmas.
I swear, I had at least 43 friends pick up an Instant Pot between November and December.
Actually, that’s a lie. I don’t have 43 friends.
However, I’m fairly confident at least a bazillion people bought one in the last couple months (how’s that for an accurate scientific analysis of Instant Pot sales?).
Did you get one?
I feel a little bit like an Instant Pot grandma since I’ve been using one for a while now. But it really is a fantastic machine. I have tons of new pressure cooker recipes to share with you this year.
For now, I hope you’re putting this chicken tortilla soup on your menu plan as soon as possible.
It’s healthy and simple and delicious and really quite perfect. Plus, with all the cooking options, you really don’t have a lot of excuses not to make it.
One Year Ago: Cashew Chicken Lettuce Wraps {20-Minute Meal}
Two Years Ago: Korean Beef and Rice {Or Quinoa}: Simple 20-Minute Meal
Three Years Ago: Tuscan Sausage and White Bean Soup
Chicken Tortilla Soup {Instant Pot, Stovetop, Slow Cooker}
Ingredients
- 1-2 teaspoons olive oil
- ½ cup diced onion
- 2 cloves garlic, finely minced
- 1 jalapeno, seeded and finely diced
- 1 medium red or green bell pepper, seeded and diced
- 1 teaspoon salt
- ½ teaspoon black pepper
- 5 cups low-sodium chicken broth
- 1 (8-ounce) can tomato sauce
- 1 (15-ounce) can diced tomatoes, undrained
- 1 (15-ounce) can black beans, rinsed and drained
- 2 teaspoons chili powder
- 1 teaspoon dried oregano
- ½ teaspoon ground cumin
- 1 ½ to 2 pounds boneless, skinless chicken breasts, cubed into 1-inch pieces (about 3 medium breasts)
- 3 to 4 corn tortillas, chopped (see note)
- 1 cup frozen corn kernels
- 1-2 tablespoons fresh lime juice
- Toppings: sour cream, shredded cheese, cilantro, lime wedges, avocados, crispy tortilla strips or chips, and other desired toppings, for serving (optional)
Instructions
- Pressure cooker: Using the saute function, heat the olive oil and saute the onion, garlic, jalapeño and bell pepper for 2-3 minutes until the onion starts to soften.
- Add the salt, pepper, chicken broth, tomato sauce, diced tomatoes, black beans, chili powder, oregano, and cumin, chicken, and chopped tortillas. Stir.
- Secure the lid and cook on high pressure for 7 minutes.
- Let the pressure naturally release for 10-15 minutes before using quick release for the remaining pressure.
- Stir in the corn and lime juice. Add additional salt and pepper to taste. Serve with desired toppings.
- Stovetop: In a 4- or 5-quart pot, heat the olive oil over medium heat, and saute the onion, garlic, jalapeño and bell pepper for 2-3 minutes until the onion starts to soften.
- Add the salt, pepper, chicken broth, tomato sauce, diced tomatoes, black beans, chili powder, oregano, and cumin. Stir.
- Bring the soup to a simmer and cook for 20 minutes.
- Add the chicken and chopped tortillas; cook for 8-10 minutes more until the chicken is cooked through.
- Stir in the corn and lime juice. Add additional salt and pepper to taste. Serve with desired toppings.
- Slow Cooker: In a skillet, heat the olive oil over medium heat, and saute the onion, garlic, jalapeño and bell pepper for 2-3 minutes until the onion starts to soften. Scrape the mixture into the slow cooker (you can skip this pre-cooking step, but I like to do it since I find that sometimes the onions don’t soften all the way when cooking).
- Add the salt, pepper, chicken broth, tomato sauce, diced tomatoes, black beans, chili powder, oregano, cumin, chicken, and chopped tortillas. Stir.
- Cook for 4-6 hours on low or 2-3 on high. Stir in the corn and lime juice. Add additional salt and pepper to taste. Serve with desired toppings.
Notes
Recommended Products
Recipe Source: from Mel’s Kitchen Cafe
177 Comments on “Chicken Tortilla Soup {Instant Pot, Stovetop, Slow Cooker}”
So so so good. I love quick, easy meals that feel gourmet. This was a hit with everyone. I do have Littles, so I swapped poblano peppers for the jalapeño. I also used ready-made rotisserie chicken so that made it even faster. Start to finish was about 30 min. Loved this soup (almost as much as your white chicken chili)!
Mel, I was in charge of the food for our stake RS luncheon. It was a tall order too— 225 women, $700 budget and requests to have gluten free menu and one that could be taken to-go for sisters not comfortable in our post-COVID world. I made 16 batches of this soup, froze it in gallon size freezer bags and reheated it in crockpots and roasting pans (adding the tortilla strips at that point). It was a HIT! After making so much of this soup I thought for sure I’d take a hard pass on the lunch I made. But I couldn’t resist and had a hearty helping for myself too! Of course, so many people asked for the recipe that the stake will be sending out the link to your recipe!
Wow, Rebecca, you are AMAZING!!
Mel I think it’s safe to say you have 43 friends. I am pretty confident you have one million forty three friends. at least.
Just made your soup this afternoon. I used a Costco rotisserie chicken. I followed all your instructions and it was amazing! Thank you for sharing. This is the only tortilla soup recipe I’ll ever want!
This is one of the best soups ever!! I’ve made it 4-5 time over the last few years. I used cornmeal tonight and have a tip. Add it it small amounts, sprinkled thinly across the surface. If you add it all at once, it clumps up. So do it gradually. 🙂
So good! Perfect soup for our super cold weather this week. I made it in the IP with whole frozen chicken breasts. Increased PC time to 15 minutes and it was perfect. Ready in under an hour. Will definitely make again.
Our family loves this! We’ve done it in the pressure cooker and the slow cooker, depending on what our schedule lookers like.
I am really picky about chicken tortilla soup and this recipe is great. I have made it numerous times in the Instant Pot. It’s the only recipe I use. Be sure to add ALL the suggested toppings. Thanks Mel!
I have made the soup several times. It is one of my favorites!
Mel, I just got an electric pressure cooker and have only made a couple recipes. A friend told me not to put tomato paste , sauce etc. in the pot because it plugs up the pressure thingy. I am seeing that you do put products with thickeners in yours. Do you have that problem or is that a personal problem?
As long as you have enough thin liquid (like broth or water) it usually isn’t a problem.
I need to make two batches of this. Can I just double the recipe in an 8 qt. IP? If so, do I need to increase the cooking time?
Thanks!
You can leave the cooking time the same if doubling (it will take the pressure cooker longer to come to pressure which compensates for any extra time the soup would need).
Any dinner recipe that gets my children to ask for seconds is a 5-star recipe in my book. Truthfully, when I opened the lid to dish out the soup I thought this wasn’t going to go over well. I was so surprised when both my 4- and 7-year-old asked for more. Hooray! Thanks for a great, simple, quick recipe!
Made this for a visit from my sister and her husband, both of whom are foodies. It was delicious. Used poblanos instead of bell peppers as both my sister and I detest bell peppers. I have now sent this recipe to my nephew who is in to eating as healthy as possible.
I made this tonight in our slow cooker so it could fit everyone’s different schedules and it was perfect. The tortillas added such a great flavor and texture. This will definitely be a repeat at our house. Thanks for such consistently delicious recipes!
Made this tonight and it was delicious. Do you have the nutritional information for this soup?
I don’t – sorry!
Made this for a family dinner tonight and it was a major hit! I sometimes have a tough time with tomatoey soups, but this one was wonderful! I doubled the beans, on the advice of my sister who recommended it to me. Good choice. Definitely putting this on my list of go-to soups!
Great recipe! My husband especially gave it rave reviews. It came together fairly quickly in the IP even though I put in 3 frozen chicken breasts and a frozen 3-cup block of broth. Will definitely make again.
Used this recipe for my first instant pot meal and it was a huge success! Only thing we changed…left out the onions since we hate onions. Absolutely delicious and will be making again. Thanks Mel!
I made this tonight in the instant pot and everyone loved it! I
Excellent – made as written with extra tortilla strips.
Thanks so much for the delicious recipe! My family loved it! I just got my 8 quart Instant Pot and this is only the 2nd time I have used it. So happy to have a great recipe right off the bat! I am wondering how I would adjust the recipe to add more chicken. I would love to make this one night and have enough for leftovers.
I added 3 lbs to the existing recipe. Was perfect and definitely gives you leftovers.
I’m preparing for our first baby. Do you think I could freeze all of the ingredients (up until the tortillas) and then thaw for the slow cooker?
I haven’t tried it, but I think that might work. Good luck!
Gotta say… since I moved from Colorado to Louisiana a year ago… I have missed my favorite foods. Vietnamese fried-and-fresh spring rolls, green chili that makes you sweat because it is made with hatch green chilis, great quality Pho, Chicago dogs, Italian beef sandwiches, smothered breakfast burritos, tapas and my favorite soup… chicken tortilla!!! Your recipe ROCKS. It will go into my catalog of recupes that I can always depend on. Thank you SOOOOOO MUCH for bringing me a taste of home.
Happy to hear that!
Hi Mel! Cant wait to make this tonight in my IP but how many does this recipe serve? Would it serve 2 adults and 3 hungry teenagers?
Hi Kathi – it serves 6-7, so yes, I think it would be perfect for your crew!
You should add how many it serves to the recipe
Hi Patti, that information is included below the recipe title.
We had this for dinner last night made in the electric pressure cooker. One of the best soups I have EVER had! Thanks for a great recipe!
Wow! This was so yummy! I especially loved how the corn tortilla strips softened and kinda dissolved. I followed the recipe but halved it because I wasn’t sure my family would love it. My husband took a bite, looked in the instant pot and said in a very disappointed voice, “you only made half a batch?!” I’ve been dreaming of it since and will definitely be putting this in our rotation.
Haha, that’s cute, Nancy!
I added a can of white beans, red beans, and 8oz more of tomato sauce. LOVE THIS!! I could eat it all week.
I made this tonight and it was dreamy! I have been following your blog forever but I never comment but this bad boy is deserving of some serious compliments! Even my 3 & 4 year old soup-hating children (what?! How did you come from my loins?) Ate it and my 4 year old informed me that it was “super yummy” so that’s a win in my book. I put a little too much chicken in it (about 3 lbs was too much for me) and I would probably add an extra corn tortilla (I only had the street taco size) for a little more texture but it was delightful! Thank you for helping me feed my family pretty much daily… they are quite grateful too!
Thanks for taking the time to comment, Leslee!
This is excellent. I used a large poblano instead of a bell but otherwise followed the recipe.
Does this recipe make too much for the 6 quart instant pot? Also should I use the soup button or just the manual high pressure button? Thanks.
This recipe works fine in the 6-quart pot; I use the manual/high pressure function.
My husband likes creamy soups. I want to make this in the insta pot is there a way to make it thick or creamy?
Haven’t tried that – sorry! You could experiment with a flour/butter/milk mixture (roux) to thicken it up. Good luck!
Really a fantastic recipe. Just perfect! I added the corn to the pressure cooker with everything else and it turned out great
So good! Made this for a few guests last night and it was a hit! It was my first time using my instant pot and my first time trying this recipe. But I knew I could trust you! It definitely did not disappoint!
My first Instant Pot success! I can always count on you, Mel!
Made this recipe tonight for my vegetarian family of 4 (two littles, ages 8 and 5). Substituted the chicken broth with 5 oz of water and a heaping teaspoon of vegetarian “better than boullion,” and subbed the chicken with 1/2 a bag of the frozen chipotle-seasoned Morningstar Farms soy “beef” crumbles. This was fantastic! It turned out more like a stew than a soup, possibly because of our modifications and was substantial. My kids both had seconds, and as the main dish, we finished the whole pot in one meal. Thanks for the recipe! We will be using this again!!
Thanks so much Mel!!! We are so grateful for your blog with all your amazing recipes!!!!!
Delicious, the whole family loved it, thanks!
I can’t wait to make this – I just got an Instant Pot for Christmas. Do you have any suggestions of cooking time for bone in chicken thighs? We tend to use those in soups for a little extra flavor.
You’d probably want to add 5-6 minutes to the cooking time.
This is one of my favorites!! I love that I can toss everything in the instant pot and just let it go!! And it is so delicious!
Here’s a story about my husband: he is ambivalent about pretty much any food that is not pizza or tacos. He’s “not really a meat and potatoes guy,” “not really a pasta guy,” etc. Dinners have essentially become me making what I want and then throwing in pizza or tacos (or both) once per week to keep him happy. The best reaction I tend to get is a halfhearted, “This is good, babe” three bites in.
Mel. MEL! My husband took one bit of this soup and said, “Ohhhhhh babe. This is REALLY good!” I almost fainted from shock and happiness.
I have enjoyed almost all of your recipes that I have tried, but this and your carnitas (note: basically tacos) are far and away his favorites. Thank you!
Haha, thanks for making me smile, Kimberly! Glad this was a hit with your husband (and that shredded beef as well – your sweet mother of pearl comment made me laugh, too).
Very, very good. I made it with a combo stovetop/crockpot method since I made it two days ahead of serving, and appreciate the way you outlined both versions. As well, the corn tortilla tip helped. Once again, a recipe we loved. Thank you, Mel.
This was so easy and delicious! Thank you so much for the instant pot directions! I have many crock pot recipes that I’m nervous to convert to instant pot- I appreciate you figuring it out for us!! This recipe is replacing my old favorite tortilla soup- such great flavor!!
My very first attempt at Instant Pot cooking. This is delicious!
This recipe is AMAZING – and I’m not even a soup fan! I added sliced corn tortillas strips before serving to absorb the liquid a bit, but that’s not even necessary. Thanks for sharing this wonderful recipe!
Thanks, Tari!
This is such a good soup. I think I could eat it once a week and not get sick of it. Made this for probably the sixth or seventh time tonight and everyone loves it. Sometimes if I don’t have the peppers or need to save a little chopping time, I’ll put in half a cup of salsa and it totally works.
I LOVE tortilla soup and this is my new favorite! Turns out perfectly in the instant pot every time. Thanks for another winner, Mel!
This is my go to soup. How well does it freeze?
I think it freezes really well – the texture’s slightly different upon thawing and reheating, but we still love it.
I made this in the instant pot tonight and it was so flavorful! I’ve made a similar version many times in the past, but without the tomatoes and lime, and the flavor was so much better following your recipe and spice/herb amounts. My family loves bean soups so I added two extra cans of beans, one black and one great northern, and I didn’t have corn tortillas so I opted for the masa harina. For anyone going this route for the thickener, I suggest mixing a little water with the masa harina first, then stirring it in. Otherwise you might end up with clumps.
We loved this, and I’ll definitely be switching to your version from now on.
Have you tried using frozen chicken with this recipe in the instant pot? Or do you think I would need to thaw it first?
Yes, I think you can use frozen chicken – you’ll want to add probably 7-8 minutes to the time.
Darn, I wish I would have seen this comment earlier. I only added 3 minutes to the time and it wasn’t cooked through in the middle. I got it out, shredded it and put it back in with the corn (and I added zucchini) and put it back in for 3 more minutes. It was fully cooked and delicious! But I think next time I’ll just add the 6-7 minutes and steam the veggies separately and add them in at the end to save time.
My Husband and I are not fans of corn tortillas, but I do like the sounds of a chopped up tortilla in my soup! Do you think I could use flour tortillas? Would that change the taste or texture? Thanks!
My guess it that a flour tortilla will become “gummy” in the soup.
That’s what I was worried about!
I kind of agree that the flour tortillas will turn gummy, but having said that, I’ve used a flour tortilla that’s a blend of corn and flour and it worked great. You could just try leaving them out and topping with crushed tortilla chips (if you like those)?
Just got my Instant Pot today and this was the first thing we cooked It was delicious!!! Will definitely be making it again!
Do you think this would freeze very well? I’m only feeding 2 or 3 and don’t want to half the recipe since I don’t want half a can of sauce, tomatoes, and beans left over…
Thank you!
Yes, I think it would freeze great!
Mel, I don’t see in the comments that anyone else had this issue, but after I had sautéed and added all ingredients but the 2.96 pounds of chicken, my 6 qt. IP was already over 2/3’s full. I finished on the stove top as I didn’t want to overfill according to the IP manual recommendation of no more than 2/3’s full. Perhaps I used more than 1/2 cup chopped onions (didn’t measure), and I used a large red pepper. Regardless, the soup was wonderful and I had an excuse to order the 8 qt. IP. (The price is reduced on Amazon right now!)
Hi Deborah – I think I use the “max” line on the Instant Pot as my guide for soups like this – that’s probably the difference. But I also have the 8-quart and love it (hope you will too!).
I meant to say 1.96 lbs. chicken. I know I’ll enjoy the 8 qt. IP even more since my daughter told me about your website and the several great recipes of yours she already tried. She has yet to be disappointed by one!
MEL!!! I just have to tell you how much I love you! Besides the fact that I made this recipe in my IP tonight and it was amazing, you have turned me into a Cook! I have always loathed dinner time, hated cooking, and convinced myself that I was really terrible at it. That is until my sis in law introduced me to your blog. Every recipe I have tried is super easy and so so tasty! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!!
Yay! That makes me so happy, Carrie!
Thank you for all of the Instant Pot options in your recipes lately. I had a few tortilla soup recipes, but this will now be my only tortilla soup recipe!!
I would love a general post about how to convert a regular recipe to Instant Pot. I’ve had some IP successes and flops. Want to stay away from the flops!
That’s a great idea…I’ll try to get something together!
I’m in love with this recipe!! Thanks!!
I’ve made a very similar version before, but instead of the onions and peppers and diced tomatoes, just used my favorite canned salsa. I love it!
This was delicious! Thanks!!! I got my IP recently too. Keep the recipes coming!
I made this soup, the pressure cooker version, and it was a hit with everyone. It was so fabulous! So yummy! I’ve made a lot of your recipes and this is the first one I am commenting on, because it was so easy and turned out so good. My husband needs to be on a low-carb diet, and this was perfect for him. (I omitted the tortilla strips.) Thanks for the recipe!
Made the stove top version of this, and it was absolutely delicious! So excited to have it for supper again tonight. That kick of lime juice at the end send it over the top. Thanks for a great recipt!
This is a great recipe! I know that stove top might not take that long, since it’s really just simmering, but there’s something about setting the IP and letting it do its thing without stirring or bothering it! My four children all gave this multiple thumbs-up (one said 50 thumbs up). The lime juice helped cut down the jalapeño spice (we want more, kids want less), and no one said “it’s too hot!” Also – the classic italian lasagna got huge thumbs up this week too – so delicious and so worth it!
Haha, 50 thumbs up. Love it!
Yup, I got the IP and LOVE it! Been singing it’s praises to everyone I know. Can’t wait to give this soup a whirl. Hubby can’t eat corn so I plan to omit the tortillas and offer corn chips as topping for everyone else.
So my instant pot sat in its box for about a month-I was quite intimidated by it. But this recipe made me pull it out. We LOVED it, so delicious and easy! I knew my first instant pot recipe had to be one of your recipes because they never fail. My husband, whose quite opinionated, said it was better than any restaurants soup. Thanks again!!
This soup was my maiden voyage recipe for my IP, and I am so happy with how it turned out! I ended up using whole chicken breasts, and just increased the time to 18 minutes. I then shredded them with my paddle attachment on my stand mixer. It turned out perfectly! Thank you for you for your awesome recipes!
I made this last night! Sooo yummy. Used bone in chicken breast and cooked for 12 minutes in the instantpot. It was very tender! Delicious!!
I made this last night for my family and a couple of my children’s friends. It was a HUGE hit. 7 bowls licked clean. I made it in the crockpot exactly as instructed. You never disappoint-thanks for another awesome recipe!
So excited to finally use my new IP with this recipe next week. I know I can always trust anything that comes from you! Looking forward to lots of recipes using the IP this year. Also, I never use corn tortillas for anything. Do you have a brand that you prefer? Thanks for everything, Mel! You’re the best. 🙂
Hey Angie! I hope you love this! I usually buy the corn+wheat tortillas at Trader Joe’s but if not, I think the Mission brand is the most widely available corn tortilla in my neck of the woods.
Made this last night for dinner–used my Instant Pot for the first time. My husband said everything I touch turns to magic–and I have you to thank for that compliment because your recipes are always so incredible. Thank you for yet another delicious, easy, dependable Mel recipe! 🙂
Hi! I am excited for this recipe! I plan to make it in a slow cooker on Sunday. I was hoping to use left over chicken from a roast chicken we are having for dinner tonight. Think that would be okay? Just toss it in at the beginning or should I wait until the last 30 minutes to put it in since it will be fully cooked before hand? Thanks!
I’d wait until the last 20-30 minutes, and then add it and let it heat through.
I made this on the stovetop tonight and it was FANTASTIC!! (Although I just discovered now that I forgot the oregano. Oops!) I thought it was perfect as is, but I think my wife (not home right now) might like the spiciness lowered a notch. What would you suggest? Omit the jalapeno? Reduce the chili powder and/or cumin?
Hi Jim, since chili powder can vary in spiciness depending on brand, I’m guessing that may be the culprit. So I’d either omit the jalapeño or reduce the chili powder by half.
Add me to the “this was awesome” fan club! I have an older, non-IP electric pressure cooker, but it still worked great. This was delish, and I agree it’s one of the best Chicken Tortilla Soup recipes I’ve made (and I’ve made a bunch). Thanks, Mel!
Glad to hear that and love that you are a non-electric pressure cooker user. I have a stovetop one I love, too, and pull it out to use it all the time.
I made this this afternoon in the slow cooker and it was really good. The only changes I made were to use chicken thighs instead of breasts and I didn’t have limes to juice so I left that out. My family really liked it!
I got an Instant Pot 2 years ago for Christmas, and I probably had only used it 10 times or so before Mel started posting recipes for it. Now I use it much more frequently and love it! This soup is the bomb! My family loved it! My daughter printed out the recipe to put in her new recipe binder she got for Christmas.
Oh, and the chicken was super tender… not how it usually turns out in my soups. Must have been the pressure cooker action.
I don’t have the tortillas, could I use tortilla chips instead?
Could certainly try…because they are pretty salty, I might just leave them out and use the chips for topping.
Okay when your recipes say they feed 6-ish is that enough to feed your family of 7? I feel like I’m always on the edge of not having enough for my big family, but doubling would be way too much. Obviously if I doubled I’d to stovetop or crockpot method. What do you think? Is it enough for your crew?
I totally hear you on this. Because my 4-year old and 11-year old aren’t super big eaters, I can get away with making recipes like this for my family of 7, if that makes sense. Serving sizes are always tricky just based on who’s eating, how old they are, and how big of an eater they are. Generally speaking, I usually note in the recipe if I’ve doubled or halved again in order to feed my family (if that makes sense). So yes, this recipe is big enough for my family, but it doesn’t yield a lot of leftovers.
Okay that makes sense. Thank you! Very helpful as always!
We added an extra cup or so of broth and some rice when we made it. That would give you an extra couple of servings without having to double it.
I got an Instant Pot for Christmas too, and tried this as my first recipe last night. (After much careful reading of the user manual!!) I was slightly nervous, but it all went well, and the whole family loved it! Thanks so much Mel!
Way to go!
I made this last night and the flavor of this soup is AMAZING! It was a huge hit with the whole family. I was super excited you posted a pressure cooker recipe since I was one of the millions who bought one just recently 😉 you’re a lifesaver as always!
Wow! The flavours were amazing in the Instant Pot! Please keep the IP recipes coming!
Do you think this could freeze well?
Yes!
I made this today and it was awesome. I was out of tomato sauce so I just put two cans of tomatoes in. Can’t imagine how good it would be if I made it right. Love the little zing that the lime juice adds. Thank you.
Hi Mel,
Yes, I got an Instant Pot on Black Friday and have loved using it. I can’t wait for more recipes. I made this soup last night and my husband loved it. (I’m a vegetarian so didn’t eat any.) The tortillas dissolved into the soup perfectly. My boys liked it but thought it was too spicy (?!). They eat guacamole all the time with jalapeños and I am careful to remove the seeds and ribs, so I don’t think that was it. Do you think I could reduce the chili powder to make it less spicy? Thanks!
Sure!
We enjoyed this for dinner tonight. Delicious!! Even my picky eater loved it. Thank you for another amazing recipe!
Yay!
I got one on Black Friday and waited until Christmas to use it. I’ll admit I was nervous as I’ve never used a pressure cooker at all. But I’ve made yogurt, roast (still need to find a perfect recipe), boiled eggs, and the other day I made your refried beans. Delish! Can’t wait to try this. Thank you thank you!
Question, I’ve noticed that most people say to use Manual for timing what they cook instead of the “Stew/Soup” “Porridge” etc. Why is that? From trial and error of those settings not working so well? Thanks for all the IP posts. I know I can trust your recipes. :0)
Bonnie – that’s a good question and my answer is that I stick to the Manual setting because I know for certain it works and don’t have the desire to fiddle around with other settings.
Made this for dinner- everyone loved it! Didn’t have tomato sauce so I used a can of tomato paste with an extra 1/2 cup of water. Thanks Mel!
Awesome!
Mel, as I’m waiting for the pressure to come down on my soup, I have to tell you how much I appreciate you giving us the 3 different cooking methods for this. I originally was going to leisurely do the stove top, but then realized didn’t have the time, so was really nice to pressure cook it. And I for one am all for more pressure cooker recipes. Think I need to say “thank you” more often. You have really made a difference in my cooking world.
Thanks, Maureen! 🙂
This was awesome! Made it in the IP yesterday and it is one of the best chicken tortilla soup I’ve made and I’ve tried a bunch. One issue I seem to have a lot with the IP is the lack of salt but with this recipe, it was perfect!
Glad to hear that, Kelly!
I’m brand new to Instant Pot–this is my first time! I have these ingredients in the pot right now and am wondering about the setting. After I saute, should I switch to the soup setting? Or Stew? Or poultry? Thanks for helping out a beginner!
Sorry for not being more clear, Melissa. After the Saute function, switch it to Manual and adjust the time.
So when using the stovetop method, you just throw the chicken in raw, and it cooks in the soup? Or do you pre-cook the chicken cubes?
The chicken cooks in the soup.
Have you ever tried doubling a recipe in instant pot? I’m wondering if I doubled this, would the cooking time change?
Hey Ashley, I don’t think a doubled recipe of this would fit safely in the Instant Pot (usually, though, you don’t have to add time if doubling, as long as it doesn’t exceed the fill line in the pressure cooker – keeping in mind that foods that expand should only fill the pressure cooker halfway full).
Yep! Received an IP for Christmas and just starting to make lots of yummy recipes with it… this one is next! I love this type of soup!
Sorry about the water leaks— that’s never fun!!! 🙁
Happy new year to ya!!
I made this last week and it was great! Thanks for another winner!! 🙂
My husband bought me an Instant Pot because he was on the bandwagon but I wasn’t so sure. He laughs because I now have become the spokesperson and tells everyone about them! By the way, I have a similar recipe for tortilla soup done on the stove and it calls for corn meal, it works great and tastes yummy.
So sorry to hear about the continuing flooding.
Although preferable to a fire, a flood is a drag: destructive and painful to clean up.
I jumped on the bandwagon and got an instant pot! I’m going to add this soup to the rotation this month. I also plan on trying your chicken and black bean chili in my instant pot.
Thanks for deciding what I’m making for dinner tonight! FYI your instructions don’t say when to include the oregano. I guessed I should put it in with the other spices?
Ooops, sorry about that! Just updated but yes, add it in with the other spices.
It was delicious! I had frozen chicken tenders, so increased the cooking time to 14 minutes to account for the frozen meat. It did take quite a while for my Instant Pot to reach pressure, but the hands-free aspect of it way outweighs the additional time. Start to finish was about an hour. I didn’t do the tortillas – just had tortilla chips in our soup. Can’t wait for leftovers tomorrow!!
So happy you liked it!
Made this in my Instant Pot tonight and it was fabulous! I do have one question though, are.the tortillas supposed to disappear into the broth?
It kind of depends on the brand/type of tortillas, but mine sometimes maintain a little texture to them. Did yours?
They were completely dissolved into the broth, the flavor was there though. So not really a bad thing.
The same thing happened to me. The soup is awesome, though.
Could I add rice to this if making it in the pressure cooker or would that change the cooking time?
You could definitely try – usually white rice cooks in 3-4 minutes and brown rice takes more like 22 minutes so I’m afraid it might be over done or under done but you could definitely experiment.
We cooked the rice on the stove using some of the broth from the soup and then added it all back into the soup. It was delicious. We’ll definitely be making this again!
i’m one of those that got an instant pot for Christmas and I’m looking forward to learning how to use it. Thanks for sharing your tried and true recipes for me to start with. This soup looks delicious
Making this for dinner! I was a Black Friday Instant Pot purchaser (thanks to your informative and enthusiastic posts singing its praises!) Looking forward to more Instant Pot recipes from you in 2017!
Mel, what was the name of your favorite pressure cooker cookbook? I remember you mentioning it, but I can’t find it.
https://www.amazon.com/Presents-Wardens-Ultimate-Pressure-Recipes/dp/1934193798/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1483402878&sr=8-2&keywords=pressure+cooker+cookbook
I tried substiting cornmeal. It works best if you whisk it with some water or broth (more liquid than cornmeal) before adding, like a cornstarch slurry, otherwise it can develop clumps. Great soup!
Thanks for the tip, Laura!
Looking for healthy low salt reciepes and I love chicken tortilla soup. Thanks it looks so good
Carol W.
If using a crockpot, you don’t add the frozen corn until cooking time is up? Do you cook for any additional amount of time?
I don’t cook it any extra. The heat of the soup warms up the corn but keeps it fresh-tasting. You could certainly try adding it during cooking or cooking it longer, if you’d like.
I agree. The heat from the soup will warm the corn enough. Cook the corn too much and it will get mushy, no?
You don’t have 43 friends?!?!? Funny, but wrong. I think you are my friend and I don’t really “know” you . I got an instant pot for Christmas and have made sweet baked ham, brown rice and mashed potatoes. Can’t wait to try this and the other recipes coming this year. Thanks for being my best virtual friend!
Raising my hand to say that YES! I jumped on the instant pot bandwagon when the Black Friday deals were too good to pass up. I love all your recipes and am thrilled to hear you’ll keep the IP recipes coming. Thanks, Mel!
This looks great and I can’t wait to try it (likely this week)! Could you combine the IP and slow cooker method and saute in the IP and then switch to slow cooker method? I am thinking I could start it before work and then it can cook all day.
if using chicken thighs (my go to for all crockpot recipes), how long in the instant pot?
You’d probably want to increase the time to 15 minutes.
Just to follow up, had the biggest boneless skinless thighs so increased time to 20 minutes, just in case. Came out perfectly! Thanks!
I had 14 friends get IP this year. I just taught a beginners class to 10 of them and have another class coming up. Can’t wait to tell them about this recipe. It sounds so good. We’re up to 18″ of snow so I think I’ll get this going right away!
This looks so yummy … and after our more than a foot of snow that fell last night, the deep freeze is setting in here in Cache Valley. Can’t wait to make this… probably will try it all ways, just ’cause I can. Oh and by the way, you have WAY more than 43 friends… Hello thousands of blog readers who all think they are your best friends… just sayin’ Love you Mel!
This sounds perfect for this super-cold back to work week! I’ve been making your creamy black bean taco soup since it came up on the Weekly Menu a week or 3 ago. This will be a nice variation.
I’ve wanted to try the creamy black bean chili in the instantpot, but not sure how to convert it. Any tips?! I’m afraid I’ll mess it up if I just try because of the flour/cheese combo. Thanks!
Jessica, Mel may have a different thought, but I’m not sure the creamy black bean taco soup is an Instant Pot candidate … it is pretty quick stovetop since you are cooking ground meat and using cooked beans … and then the roux part, i.e. there is no long time cooking needed and it is not really a “‘dump in and go”.
However, you could try searching for “creamy soups Instant Pot” or “roux in Instant Pot” and see what comes up.
I couldn’t have said it any better myself! Those would be by exact thoughts, Jessica. Using the IP for the creamy black bean soup wouldn’t save you anytime…and roux mixtures can be kind of finicky in the IP.